# 7: Capturing Mary (2007)

Maggie Smith

as Mary Gilbert

in

Capturing Mary (2007) (TV)

Screentime: 43 minutes and 29 seconds (44.8% of the film)

An orthodox choice I admit to pick so early, but Capturing Mary is the story of a young man named Joe letting in an older woman by the name of Mary into an empty and unoccupied house where she begins to tell her story and experiences many years earlier in the same residence. Here, the film juxtaposes between the present elderly and alcohol dependent Mary and the beautiful and up and coming journalist Mary in the 1950s. At a party, with guests such as Alfred Hitchcock in attendance, the young Mary meets a mysterious man named Grenville White that would change her life forever. Initially rather warm to Mary, he begins to act rather creepy and opens up to her and reveals horrible and shocking details about the lives of various famous people, and afterwards of all things offers a key to his house which she refuses and leaves and doesn’t speak to him again.

For reasons not exactly clear, despite only seeing him again at a few parties in the next 10 years, this encounter somehow affects the rest of Mary’s life up to the present causing psychological harm to her. His presence in her mind doesn't allow her to write new material in the ‘60s without leading back to that night, all her work with potential clients are cut short when Grenville goes behind her back and ruins her reputation and she starts drinking. The whole first half of the film was rather irritating and confusing, how could this man be so influential? Was I missing something? I mean 50 years on there is Mary still panicking at the ghost of him while she is at the park... The elements of the film didn’t click, I understand to a degree what the film was trying to get across about the different class systems of the 1950s, the longing influences people leave and how certain decisions can make an eternity of change but I honestly wasn’t a fan of the material. The performances, in particular, Maggie Smith (of course) and her younger self, Ruth Wilson were worth mentioning. For that I give the film, a generous:

 FILM:

Maggie Smith was her wonderful self and in thefilm she projects a Vanessa Redgrave in Atonement quality/vibe in her monologues and narration to the flashbacks, her fragility as she walks around an empty room or the way she glances and tears up as memories races through her head were brilliantly subtle. The final 20 minutes is her moment to shine, and although I mentioned before some aspects of the film is rather weak, Smith’s acting simply elevates the material. You want to give the woman a long hug for all the mental damage she has endured, and Smith portrays this in a heartbreaking and delicate manner.

MAGGIE-METER:

"This isn't a ghost story, no... this is worse than a ghost story. For me anyway"
 

 

# 6: Gosford Park (2001)

Maggie Smith

as Constance Trentham

in

Gosford Park (2001)

 

Screentime: 20 minutes and 41 seconds* (16.2% of the film)

* I should note here that screentiming this performance was a bit of a nightmare, when I time any of Maggie's performances, whenever she is featured or heard contributes to her time, therefore if a scene obvious features her but the camera is NOT on her, then that doesn't include her screentime. Robert Altman's style here in Gosford Park is easing in and out of multiple conversations, so at many times you can *just* hear Maggie speaking or *just* see her to the left or right. Additionally there are sequences where her character is in the car, but she (the actor) isn't necessarily there. I decided to only include sequences where you can obviously see her through the windows of the car.

Robert Altman’s Gosford Park is a murder-mystery/drama/comedy about a group of British high society and their servants coming together to the Gosford Park estate for a weekend of shooting and socialising. The film focuses on the lives of probably 40 characters and the liaisons, secrets and resentments that leads to the murder of the man of the house late at night. A detective arrives on the scene to investigate and find answers as to who is guilty and what was the motive as the weekend comes to a close. 

One may think the film sounds like the typical Agatha Christie mystery, but the who-dunnit? theme really takes the backburner instead to focus more on the simultaneous storylines of the guests and workers. The script is wonderful and all the actors deliver and perform their individual subplots wonderfully. The film is a major ensemble piece and the cast is to die for: Dame Maggie, Helen Mirren, Emily Watson, Michael Gambon, Stephen Fry, Ryan Phillipe, Kristin Scott Thomas, Clive Owen, Kelly Macdonald, Alan Bates, Eileen Atkins and Kristin Scott Thomas. I don’t know if it’s just me but the whole Upstairs-Downstairs scenario is just so entertaining to watch, and for that I give the film:

FILM:

 

Maggie Smith’s character Constance Trentham opens and closes the film with her maid Mary arriving and leaving the estate. Smith is wonderful and hilarious as the bitchy and snobby woman who despite her lavish lifestyle is starting to suffer some financial issues. It seems the entire weekend she just lives off the free food and any form of gossip spreading from both upstairs and downstairs and this makes her character so delightful. She deservingly got nominated for an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress but it’s a rather low key role, she doesn’t get any Oscar scenes or breakdowns (unlike her co- nominee Helen Mirren) but she still stands out with those snarky comments or reactions. She’s a hoot and a natural for this type of comedy.

MAGGIE-METER:
 

(To her maid) "That settles it. Come back at half past eight. I'll get dressed. It's the greatest bore, of course, but I don't want to miss anything."

# 2: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (2007)

Maggie Smith

as Professor Minerva McGonagall 

in

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (2007)

Screentime: 3 minutes and 11 seconds (2.43% of film)

Order of the Phoenix is an entertaining installment, that mainly focuses on the Ministry of Magic and its interference on Hogwarts as well as romance, exams and secret societies. The film features an Oscar nomination worthy performance from Imelda Staunton (I could also see Brenda Blethyn do wonders with the role), and sticks very closely to the book. Again a very well done film. 

FILM: 4/5

Maggie I believe has either a total of 4 of 5 lines in the film. A third of her screentime is in the background at the first great hall scene, she was utterly wasted in her part. I believe in the book, she attempts to help Hagrid when he is being evicted from the school grounds and gets multiple stunning spells to the chest, causing her to go to hospital. There are set photos of Maggie filming additional scenes, but they do not even appear on the DVD (they most likely were removed early on without any post-production editing). 

MAGGIE-METER: 1/5

 "Oh, there are several things I would like to say!"

# 1: Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004)

Maggie Smith

as Professor Minerva McGonagall 

in

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004)

Screentime: 3 minutes and 7 seconds (2.42% of film)

Prisoner of Azkaban, is in my opinion the best Potter film, along with both of the Deathly Hallows finales. I feel 'Prisoner' was the beginning of a more mature and adultish focus on the books and with Alfonso Cuaron’s unique direction (he later did the amazing Children of Men (2006)), the overall film was quite brilliant. Radcliffe’s voice broke, Emma Watson started blossoming and Gary Oldman gave a wicked performance as Sirius Black. I might add it was probably the most entertaining book. 

Film: 4/5

As for dear Maggie, she is barely in it. I mean she unfortunately gets NOTHING to do, which really sucks. In the first two installments she seemed to be a bit more apart of Harry and the Griffindor student's lives. There is one scene however that she gets a little chunk of dialogue, and she is sharing the scene with none other than Julie Christie herself (she is in only one 90 second scene). Anyway there is nothing to extensively report unfortunately. Great film, with barely any Maggie.

MAGGIE-METER:             1.5/5

 "Sirius Black was and remains today... Harry Potter's godfather."

Please Note: There is a 2 minute deleted scene of Maggie and the Gryffindor gang on the DVD, the scene is on YouTube if you haven't seen it. It was a decent scene of McGonnagal taking charge on her house with the Sirius Black hysteria and an apparent break-in.